StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...

Culture, Social Status and Identity in Viramontes' The Months and Tan's Rules of the Game - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Instructor Class 20 June 2012 Culture, Social Status, and Identity in Viramontes’ “The Moths” and Tan’s “Rules of the Game” People are social beings, who crave to belong to their society, but not all people think this way. In Viramontes’ “The Moths” and Tan’s “Rules of the Game,” two girls defy pre-existing social and cultural beliefs about womanhood and self-identity…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.9% of users find it useful
Culture, Social Status and Identity in Viramontes The Months and Tans Rules of the Game
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Culture, Social Status and Identity in Viramontes' The Months and Tan's Rules of the Game"

Download file to see previous pages

These stories are the same because they depict the cultural and social status of their characters, and the main protagonists want to mold identities that conflict with their society’s beliefs about womanhood, but they are different, because they discover dissimilar sanctuaries, where they can be, who they are, without being judged. These short stories are the same, because they portray the cultural and social status of the characters. The beliefs and practices of the protagonist in “The Moths” demonstrate that she comes from a conservative and patriarchal society.

This society demands their women to be submissive and skilled in feminine tasks and values, such as crocheting. Her father, who she calls Apa, often gets angry with her, because she dislikes going to church. As part of their conservative and religious culture, they are expected to go to mass every Sundays, especially decent girls and women. But she does not does not like the church, because its “vastness” makes her feel alone (Viramontes). Likewise, in “Rules of the Game,” Waverly’s Chinese is culture is very conservative, where hierarchies exist.

On top of the family hierarchy are parents, who children will and should never disobey. When Waverly’s mother says this, she embodies the “strong wind” in her daughter’s life: “Strongest wind cannot be seen” (Tan). She cannot see her mother, who is always at her back, watching and commenting on her every move, not only in chess, but in real life. The social status of the characters is also evident in the settings of the story. The protagonist in “The Moths” lives in a place where superstitions are respected.

Her grandmother mixes dried moth wings with Vicks to soothe her “bull hands” and shrink them back to normal size (Viramontes). Her grandmother also has stomach cancer, but they do not have money to pay for expensive therapies. Similarly, Waverly lives in a poor community, although she is not aware that she is poor. They live on a “…two-bedroom flat that sat above a small Chinese bakery” (Tan). It signifies living in a cramped and controlled space, where Waverly cannot expect to express her freedoms.

These stories are also the same, because the female protagonists challenge their cultures, in order to form their identities. The protagonist in “The Moths” does not believe in following cultural norms about womanhood. Instead of learning how to crochet, she learns how to plant with her grandmother. Her “bull hand” signifies that she does not fit with her society, because her personality, preferences, and beliefs oppose female stereotypes and Christian norms. When she smells the chile, she cries not only because of the chile’s spice on her eyes, but also because of herself.

She is like a chile that hurts the feelings of her family, who wants her to be someone she is not. She is also compared to the “defiant” sun, because they both resist changing for others (Tan). When the sun meets the land during sunset, the union depicts that “endings” are windows to “rebirths” (Tan). But if she will be reborn, she will be the same pertinent and critical daughter that makes Apa angry and disappointed. Also, Waverly defies her culture, by becoming a great chess player and toppling every other man or boy she plays with. Moreover,

...Download file to see next pages Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Culture, Social Status and Identity in Viramontes' The Months and Essay”, n.d.)
Culture, Social Status and Identity in Viramontes' The Months and Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1453266-compare-contrast
(Culture, Social Status and Identity in Viramontes' The Months and Essay)
Culture, Social Status and Identity in Viramontes' The Months and Essay. https://studentshare.org/english/1453266-compare-contrast.
“Culture, Social Status and Identity in Viramontes' The Months and Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1453266-compare-contrast.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Culture, Social Status and Identity in Viramontes' The Months and Tan's Rules of the Game

Media, Culture and Identity

Media plays an important role in the formation of culture and identity in that it has increased the level of mobility that the community has access to.... The media technology also brings change in cultural identity in that it increases the level of self sufficiency among the members of the given community.... Instructor: Media, Culture, and identity The formation of a people's cultural identity is a complex process that is often influenced by many factors....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Social Theory and Culture Identity

He further elucidates the relationship between cultures and identity - according to him, in the postmodern condition, cultures seem to be rather fragmented; and in addition, this fragmented culture allows individuals to select their own identities.... (Adapted from Powell & Moody, 2003) This dissertation shall briefly analyze, the evolution of the concepts of identity and community and their significance in contemporary social thought, through the constructs of social theorists like Zygmut Bauman, Heelas, Alasdair MacIntyre, Chales Taylor, and Selingman etc....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

An Analysis of the Black Race

Considering these ideas, this paper draws on scholarly articles to discuss the intertwining concepts of race, ethnicity, and identity.... The Black subject stems from issues related to race, ethnicity, and identity.... As Blacks and those who are considered non-white continue to suffer from racial and ethnic tensions worldwide, issues on race, ethnicity, and identity will continue to prevail in the society.... Before discussing the origin of the Black subject, it is essential to understand the concepts of race, ethnicity, and identity....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Consumer Culture in terms of Social Status and Identity

Consumer culture, individualism, individual strive for success, and materialism became the dominant identity factor, which portrayed then and still does, Man's ultimate gains (Cross, 2002).... Jhally (2006) portrays that this is what has come to define our current society, the geopolitical, social and economic factors notwithstanding.... Despite the great expansion of government, the very basic ideal of political life being primary to social coexistence and human interaction, it has receded to the background; paving way for a consumer public....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

The Notion of Identity and Social Roles

nbsp; Across the globe, racial inequity is widespread and skin color sets about an issue of social status.... This essay "The Notion of identity and Social Roles" focuses on the concept of identity frames that illustrates the various ways in which people view themselves in the context of specific conflicts.... hellip; identity spans across the different fields of inquiry, making its way through varied interpretations as the mere representation of a self....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Language, Culture and Identity

"Language, Culture and identity" paper takes a look at the relationships of language, culture, and identity from a viewpoint of terminology and through theories advanced regarding their relationships with each other.... hellip; Language, culture, and identity are characteristics of peoples.... The relationship between language, culture, and identity has been the subject of many debates because of the implications they bring to language teaching and language policy....
11 Pages (2750 words) Coursework

Culture and Identity Changes

It concerned only those who carried residential status and Saudi passports.... Thus they do not attempt to make any effort to teach their younger children the ways of the Iraqi culture as they may have to their elder children.... The aim of this part of the study is to determine where this younger generation is heading, and whether it is away from the values and cultural inclinations of their parents, and further to what extent this creates increased generational conflicts within the family....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment

Puerto Rican Culture & Identity

hellip; Puerto Rican culture and identity issues lie in the multi-cultural and multi-racial roots of the country.... Throughout history, these concepts had been used to foster legitimacy and identity among individuals or groups, as well as to create divisions and conflicts.... From the paper "Puerto Rican Culture & identity" it is clear that the Puerto Rican family was a large, three-generation family living in the same home or as neighbors....
14 Pages (3500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us