StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Joel Bakans Argument in The Corporation - Book Report/Review Example

Summary
The author of this review "Joel Bakan’s Argument in The Corporation" states that the basic premise of the book holds that the corporation, which is considered a legal person under legal standards, can only be a psychopath, as evident from its characteristics and the personality it projects…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Joel Bakans Argument in The Corporation
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Joel Bakans Argument in The Corporation"

The corporation is a book ed by Joel Bakan, a filmmaker, and a law at the of British Columbia, the book was published in February 2004; it explores the political, economic, and the social facets of corporations. The book is an account of reform – guided by deep and wide research – giving insider views and authoritative pointers about the entity of the corporation. The book revolves around the argument that – as an economic and legal entity – the corporation is fundamentally, pathological in nature: the corporation prioritizes the profit motive above all accountability and social value standards. Bakan goes ahead to point out that recent changes, particularly those related to corporate scandals are pushing companies towards the adoption of social responsibility. In supporting his views, he builds upon the claims that, corporations are allowed by legal principles, to elevate their interests above those of others, which encourages them to exploit others without regard for moral or legal directives (Bakan 56). Further, he bases his views on the claim that the corporation’s unchecked self-interest abuses the rights of shareholders, individuals, and exploits the environment – which could cause the self-destruction of the corporation. Other claims presented by Bakan include that governments have renounced the need to control the corporation, regardless of its defective character – by allocating it freedom from legal restraints – through the processes of deregulation and privatization. Bakan views that privatization offers the corporation immense authority over the society (Bakan 72-73). In conclusion, Bakan argues that the structural failures in many corporations can be remedied through far-reaching reform – through imposing democratic control and legal regulation (Bakan 79). Discussion The basic premise of the book holds that, the corporation, which is considered a legal person under legal standards, can only be a psychopath, as evident from its characteristics and the personality it projects. In supporting the view that the corporation can only qualify to be a psychopath, Bakan argues from a psychologist’s perspective that the legal person of a corporation can be attributed to a number of personality traits (Bakan 56). First, the corporation would be irresponsible, as it subjects other entities: shareholders, individuals and the environment at risk, throughout the pursuit for its goals. Bakan’s idea that the corporation is irresponsible is supported by Coors and Winegarden (2005), where they point out that focusing on pleasing all stakeholders will drive the corporation out of business. Bakan, also points out that the corporation is manipulative, as it manipulates the different stakeholders, during the pursuit for the goals it sets to realize. Bakan argues that the corporation is reckless, as it does not assume responsibility for its own actions, especially when the actions are negative. Coors and Winegarden (2005) support Bakan’s ideas, arguing that the corporation is simply a reflection of the priorities and the demands of its consumer population, some changes in its outlook results from a change of the demands of its consumers. This shows that the corporation manipulates its stakeholders and the environment, to ensure that their interests conform to its struggle to meet the changing consumer needs. The recklessness of the corporation is depicted by Coors and Winegarden (2005), who argue that all CSR efforts are merely corporate advertising that seeks to increase consumer knowledge of the corporation’s products. Bakan presents the argument that the corporation is remorseless, as it does not show any remorse, in the cases where it has done something that is perceivably wrong (Bakan 80). Moreover, corporations are grossly remorseless, from the case of Shell Nigeria, which is releasing uncontained poisonous gases into the atmosphere, making it one among the worst pollution-causing agents in the world. The remorselessness of the corporation was exhibited; according to Achbar et al. (n.d), by the company’s opposition towards Ken Wiwa and eight other activists – after they opposed the operations of the shell company in the Niger Delta. Bakan argues that the corporation is also a psychopath, in its very nature, as it deals relates with others in a superficial manner: it relates with other parties, stakeholders, and society in ways that do not reflect their real values. This view of Bakan is supported by Achbar et al (n.d), who argue that corporations invest in perception management, in order to ensure that they keep their businesses alive. Achbar et al (n.d) point out that Lucy Hughes, states that the “nag factor” is a strategy used by corporations, during the designing of promotions and advertisements, to ensure that children nag their parents for the products being advertised more effectively. Lucy Hughes adds that the “nag factor” is a game that corporations play, towards manipulating the needs of the consumers, so they can buy their products. This attribute shows that their dealings, in general, are superficial – as they project value to the customer, while in the real sense pursuing the creation of a market, through appealing to their changing needs and wants (Bakan, 2004). Bakan notes that not all corporations are psychopaths, but the organizational structure of corporations is what makes their actions incline towards those of psychopaths. Primarily, the structure of the corporations insists on the single goal of increasing profits and escalating share value, while giving other areas secondary role. Bakan’s argument that the corporation is primarily, an entity seeking monetary value is supported by Achbar et al (n.d), which explains the case of Steve Wilson and Jane Akre, who were fired by Fox News after declining the demands of the company, to water down an account written about rBGH. The issue at hand was the harmful effect of the milk produced by the cows administered with the chemical – which reduces human resistance to diseases. The corporations involved in the saga were Monsanto, the manufacturer of rBGH and FOX news. The particular case shows the insensitivity of the two corporations, as Monsanto – knowing the effects of the chemical – threatened FOX news, in the case it lets the news out to the public (Achbar et al n.d). FOX news, on the other hand, sought to protect its welfare by threatening the two investigative journalists, who refused to disregard the story, which led to the loss of their jobs. Therefore, the case shows that both corporations were largely motivated by the need to increase profits and swell the value of their shares, regardless of the damage caused by the products on the users of the product. Bakan, in concluding the discussion on the flaws of the current corporations and the structure that houses it, proposes that the solution will not be ending the activities of corporations or the business model as a whole. However, he proposes the need to subject their existence to laws, and places emphasis on the need to give the same laws, power to dissolve the corporation, in the case the situation warrants that. In maintaining the view, Achbar et al (n.d) note the case of a strategic partnership between IBM and Nazi Germany, which was mainly a profit-making effort, employed due to the lack of democratic rule. Bakan insists that there is a need for the law to guide the structure, expressing exactly what it can and what cannot do – based on legal constructions – where necessary, controlling its power under a functional democracy (Bakan, 2004). In support of the idea, Achbar et al (n.d) note the case of Bolivia, where a corporation brought in to privatize the water system by the government was fought by the citizens. The case demonstrates the need to subject the operations and the functionality of corporations to democratic rule, in order to ensure that they act in the interest of the majority. Bakan proposes stronger regulation of corporations by the government, developing a strong public sphere, improving political democracy, and limiting market fundamentalism (Bakan, 2004). Conclusion The corporation is a book authored by Joel Bakan, and published in 2004; the book explores the economic, social and the political aspects of corporations: it accounts for the need for reforms in the operations, the entity and the control of corporations. Bakan argues that the corporation prioritizes profit making above all standards of accountability and social standards. However, he notes that the increasing need to engage in CSR has forced many corporations to forge care for the environment, society and stakeholders, although most of the CSR efforts are corporate advertising strategies. In supporting his views, he presents the claims that corporations are psychopathic entities, which are characterized by the following characteristics: irresponsible, manipulative, remorseless, reckless, and superficial. Bakan’s ideas are supported by other writers like Coors and Winegarden and Achbar et al., showing that corporations should be controlled by the legal system – if they are to operate without exploiting others and the environment. References Achbar, M., Abott, J., and Bakan, J. (n.d) “The Corporation: A film by Mark Achbar, Jeniffer Abbott & Joel Bakan”. Metrodome, 3-10. Retrieved from http://hellocoolworld.com/files/TheCorporation/TheCorporationPressNotes2.pdf Bakan, J. (2004). The Corporation: The Pathological Pursuit of Profit and Power. Key West, FL: Free Press. Coors, A., and Winegarden, W. (2005) “Corporate Social Responsibility—or Good Advertising?” Regulation, 10-11. Retrieved from http://www.cato.org/sites/cato.org/files/serials/files/regulation/2012/8/v28n1-noted.pdf Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Joel Bakans Argument in The Corporation

Critically analyze Joel Bakan's argument in the book The Corporation

the corporation is a book authored by Joel Bakan, a filmmaker, author and a law professor at the University of British Columbia, the book was published in February 2004; it explores the political, economic, and the social facets of corporations.... The book is an account of reform – guided by deep and wide research – giving insider views and authoritative pointers about the entity of the corporation.... The book revolves around the argument that – as an economic and legal entity – the corporation is fundamentally, pathological in nature: the corporation prioritizes the profit motive above all accountability and social value standards....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Business and society. Critically analyze Joel Bakans argument in the book The Corporation

in the corporation, Bakan introduces corporations as the instruments of evil and corruption, which could be tamed and restrained by pursuing a range of reforms.... In the book the corporation, Joel Bakan tries to analyze the fact that if corporation would have been a person, what would its personality profile be?... n the Chapter One, Bakan goes on to elaborate on the origins of the corporation in a historical perspective.... The limited liability granted to the corporation was not only protected by the law, but also flowed out of the immense wealth owned by the corporations....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Critical Analysis of Joel Bakans Argument in the Corporation Book

"Critical Analysis of Joel Bakan's argument in the corporation Book" paper states that corporations in the modern economy contribute to the escalating inflation, the violence, and environmental degradation.... This relinquishes the corporation from other public policies such as public procurement and other management policies that govern public bodies....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

Joel Bakans Argument in the book the Corporation

The paper "joel bakans argument in the book the Corporation" highlights that generally, in the US, corporations have the tendency of elevating their status and make their own decisions.... Joel continues to show in his book the way the corporation diverts the democratic process through donations and lobbying.... However, Joel Bakan does not stop at the illegality of the corporation but also offers insight on how evil can be fought and the balancing of power provided back to the citizens....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

The Variety of Evils in Corporation

Corporations have turned into vehicles through which well brought up men and women cause havoc to society due to the way the corporation is developed and safeguarded by law.... The author takes his audience through the beginning of the corporation in form, as well as its legal status.... The author then provides terrible tales, which indicate the variety of evils that the corporation has committed on this earth.... This terminated the grant theory of the corporation, an assumption that corporations were offered their legality by the state, and; therefore, only had limited permission for what they could carry out and the period they could function....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Critical Analysis of the Arguments against Corporate Power as Presented in Joel Bakans Book

By living in an autonomous society, there are numerous instances in which propositions and oppositions towards corporate power have been identified, and one such instance is as presented by Joel Bakan in his most famous book, the corporation.... ritical AnalysisFirst, the analogy as presented by Bakan is that of a brilliantly debated account of the pathological pursuit of power and profits by a corporation, and in it, he chiefly argues that even though a corporation is a product of legal procedures, it functions like a psychopathic person....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Arguments Against Corporate Power in Joel Bakans Book The Corporation

The paper "Arguments Against Corporate Power in Joel Bakan's Book the corporation" highlights that a critical analysis of the Bakan's criticism of the corporate power shows that Bakan wasn't only against the corporation power, but also against the capitalist system of economy.... As long as the corporation does not force the state to grant its wishes, the corporation is justified in lobbying and influencing the government to grant its wishes....
11 Pages (2750 words) Book Report/Review

Arguments Against Corporate Power in Joel Bakans Book The Corporation

The paper "Arguments Against Corporate Power in Joel Bakan's Book the corporation" states that the main theme of the book is the claim that the modern corporation has caused its harm because this is the first time-limited liability has effectively existed in the present society.... This will enable the corporation to have total control of the corporation.... This will lead to the destruction of the corporation in the business market....
9 Pages (2250 words) Book Report/Review
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us